THE HALL
OF SHAME

Some reviews need a response.

Most Recent First

Milena Sciullo Google Reviews
★★★★★
#Link copied

me and my friends got ice cream sundaes we received them and they were already melted and foaming of bubbles it was a spit like consistency. we went up to the counter to ask if this was normal And they replied that this is what the ice cream looks like during off-season. It’s a little bit different. The young girl was very rude. she did not offer to fix it nor give us a refund. I’m very disappointed. considering it was an eight dollar Sundae. my friend had gone a week before and her ice cream was normal.

Jones' Shakes Response

Soft serve is soft. That isn't a flaw we forgot to fix. It's the whole point of the product. A soft-serve base is smooth, creamy and made to be eaten with a spoon, and that's exactly how it's supposed to come out of the machine. If you were expecting something hard-packed, that's a different dessert, and it isn't what we make.

Then there's the part about our team member. She stayed calm while she was being cursed at. She didn't raise her voice, she didn't argue back, and she kept doing her job. The video shows it plainly. That isn't rude. That's more patience than most people would manage in the same spot.

We won't let one of our people be painted as the villain for staying professional under pressure. We'll stand behind her every time.

Frederick H. Yelp · Oct 31, 2026
★★★★★
#Link copied

Vanilla ice cream was flavorless and grainy, not smooth. Chocolate shake was ho hum, nothing special. The neighbor was burning a big pile of who knows what and the smoke was hanging in front of the order window.

Jones' Shakes Response

It's difficult to know how to respond to a review like this. Between a neighbor's activities that are entirely outside our control, describing Marburger Dairy's vanilla soft serve as 'flavorless,' and calling a chocolate shake we've sold more than 20,000 of in just the past five months 'ho hum,' there's not much valid feedback to work with here. Not every product will appeal to everyone, of course, but this seems less like a review of a genuine experience and more like a determination to find fault with everything. We hope you got all that negativity out of your system today focused on us and didn't focus it on anyone else.

Denny Powell Google Reviews · Oct 20, 2026
★★★★★
#Link copied

It takes forever to get our ice cream products. People behind us got their milkshakes before we did. Portions are not always the same.. One lady came and saw how many people were waiting and left. My friend got his ice cream in a bowl and I was finally served 10 to 15 minutes afterwards

Jones' Shakes Response

Seven minutes. That was the wait, start to finish.

You ordered ice cream. That is not something that takes forever. It took seven minutes.

Someone behind you can get a milkshake while your ice cream is still being finished. Shakes and ice cream come from different stations. That is not skipping you. That is two different products coming out at different speeds.

Portions are finished by hand. They will not match to the ounce every time, and they are not supposed to. They are supposed to be full. Ours are.

Calling seven minutes forever, and then calling it 10 to 15 minutes afterwards, does not make either one true. The wait was seven minutes. Be accurate.

Google User Google Reviews · Sep 18, 2026
★★★★★
#Link copied

I was ignored by several employees while waiting to order. Very awkward to make eye contact with someone and then they just walk away from the window. They only had one other car in the parking lot. Maybe they had a lot of online orders. Probably about 5-8 people working. The food was okay. Edit to add it was daylight when this occurred. It was obvious the employees saw me and quickly walked away.

Jones' Shakes Response

Nobody walked away from you. Nobody saw you and decided not to help.

Glass glares in the sun. From inside, on a bright day, the window can make it hard to see who's standing outside. Night is no better. After dark, the lit interior turns that window into a mirror, and staff see their own reflection instead of the parking lot. That's exactly why there's a button by the window. It's there so nobody has to wonder whether we know they're waiting. One press and we're there.

The fix was a few inches away, and it would have taken one second. Instead of pressing it, you decided our team was walking away from you on purpose. That isn't what happened.

A Local Guide should know to look for it before writing a review. The button was there. You just didn't press it.

Judy Bromley Google Reviews · Jul 18, 2025
★★★★★
#Link copied

Young female manager very incompetent dealing with customers. I ordered 2 hot fudge Sundaes and after about 10 min l got one of the girls attention . Then the manager stated the they were coming now. After a few mins I asked again. The rude manager with her fakeness about her attitude and smiling then told me that the machine was broke but they were almost ready and shut the window in my face after I already paid for my order. So I feel like if they would have told me that the machine wasn't working right when they were first aware of the problem, I would have ordered something else. When I finally did get my order the ice cream was like milk and the hot fudge was not hot at all. I guess that they put the ice cream in the bowls first and because of the problem with the machine,the ice cream melted while waiting to put the not so hot fudge in the bowl . What a waste of money and ice cream because it just tasted bad. Not getting any of our hard earned money anymore. Look at the picture! Need I say more. Just incompetent . Laughing at her coworkers while her expressing her poor customer service . No matter what she writes below

Jones' Shakes Response

Ms. Bromley was a challenge from the start. Rude to the order taker, who also was the manager at the time. But then she struggled to accept that when a hot fudge machine runs out, that it requires a series of steps - removal of the old can, placement of a new one, getting the fudge heated. Normal stuff. But she wasn't going to accept any of that. She stood at the window and demanded answers. When our manager gave explanation and that it was just going to take a few more minutes, she started cursing, including in front of minors. We chose not to report this to the police, although the statute of limitations hasn't run out...

Chad Hines Google Reviews · Jun 21, 2024
★★★★★
#Link copied

Peach pie shake did not taste like peach at all, tasted like it had bad cream or something, they would not remake it or refund. The manager just said she could ask if it was made right. Obviously it wasn’t because not the first time having it. Done with this place after this experience. Paid 6 dollars to throw something in the trash.

Jones' Shakes Response

Vanilla soft serve, milk, peaches, and a slice of pie - nothing was stale, nothing off. Every shake is made by hand with real ingredients, and we don't cut corners on the one ingredient that matters most.

Nobody else who had a Peach Pie shake that day had a problem. Not one. If the cream had been bad, it wouldn't have been bad for just one cup. And of course we monitor all things freshness wise since we stand by our product.

Then there's the other review from another "Hines." Two 1-star reviews from the same household, amazing how this guy's ability to taste the real thing was so scarring that it warranted two separate reviews to try to burn us.

If we make your shake wrong, we fix it. If you just happen to not like the shake flavor you ordered, well we know it's great, and we're not going to carry the cost for your taste buds' free adventure. Having run means taking on a little risk. Peach pie is a safe one - one of our top sellers - and for whatever reason this guy didn't like it, it got personal. Yikes.

Beckah Hines Google Reviews · Jun 21, 2024
★★★★★
#Link copied

Nasty is all I can say I even took it to the manager and they didn’t offer to remake it or anything. Extremely disappointed. Jones used to be the place to go but now it sucks and i won’t be going back. Shake tasted like rotten pie and spoiled milk

Jones' Shakes Response

At the window you told us it was "all right." That's on our audio. You didn't ask for a remake, you didn't say anything tasted off, and you didn't raise a single concern while we were standing right there and able to help.

The words above showed up later, online, after you'd left and after there was nothing left for us to fix.

We make every shake by hand with real ingredients and fresh dairy that's rotated on schedule. If anything had really been spoiled, we'd want to know right away, and we'd have taken care of it on the spot. That's the whole reason we're standing at the window.

We'll go with what you said to our faces.

DConHeels Editor Google Reviews · Aug 3, 2020
★★★★★
#Link copied

Milk shakes weren't as good as the hype. The strawberry pretzel salad shake had not real strawberries in it, just the fake syrup & medicinal taste.

Jones' Shakes Response

Every Strawberry Pretzel Salad shake we make has real strawberries in it. Every single one. That isn't a slogan and it isn't a sometimes thing. Real strawberries are part of the recipe, and the recipe doesn't change depending on who's in line or what day it is. There is no syrup version of this shake. There never has been.

So what's written above isn't a matter of taste or opinion. It's a factual claim, and it's false. You can dislike a shake. You can decide it wasn't worth the trip. That's your right. What you can't do is invent an ingredient that isn't there, remove one that is, and present it to the public as something that happened.

Our shakes are made by hand, one at a time, right in front of the window. Anyone standing there can watch the strawberries go in. Nothing is hidden in the back, and nothing comes out of a pump bottle labeled "strawberry flavor." That's the whole point of how Jones' Shakes works, and it's why people drive out of their way for it.

We answered this the day it was posted, and the answer hasn't changed: real strawberries, no syrup. Repeating something false doesn't make it true, and a title like "editor" doesn't make it accurate. If anything, it should mean checking the facts before publishing them.

This one goes in the Hall of Shame because it's simply made up.

Jamie Exline Google Reviews · Jul 3, 2019
★★★★★
#Link copied

Disappointed that they shut fryers off when asked for food when it was an hour before closing times.😞

Jones' Shakes Response

The last hour is Shake Happy Hour, desserts only after 9, and it's posted.

That schedule isn't an accident and it isn't us cutting corners. We're a shake shop first. In the last hour we focus on what we do best, so every guest at the window gets a shake made by hand, with real ingredients, without the line backing up behind the fryers.

We'd rather be clear and consistent about it than make exceptions that slow everyone else down.

The hours are posted. Not reading them isn't our failure.

Sally Handers Google Reviews · Jan 9, 2018
★★★★★
#Link copied

Literally so overpriced it’s gross. Really high and mighty, rude employers. The employees are pretty great young people though. You’re passive aggressive and I saw a rat on the wall once.

Jones' Shakes Response

"Once," at some point, with no report to us and no report to the health department. If a guest ever sees a problem in our shop, we want to hear about it that day, so we can deal with it that day. Nobody told us anything. Our inspections speak for themselves.

Real ingredients cost real money. Real fruit, real cookies, real candy and fresh dairy, put together by hand by a person, cost more than syrup and powder. We pay that on purpose, because it's what makes the shake worth buying.

"High and mighty" just means we have standards. We care about what goes in the cup, about respect for our team, and about getting things right. We're not going to apologize for that.

A rat nobody reported and a price you didn't like don't add up to one star. They add up to a grudge.

Veggie Google Reviews · Oct 12, 2016
★★★★★
#Link copied

this is crazy its in the middle of butt freak no where

Jones' Shakes Response

Our neighbors call it home, and they're proud of it. So are we.

We chose this spot on purpose. We like being part of a community where people know each other. Every shake we make here is made by hand with real ingredients, the same way it would be anywhere else, and maybe a little better because we know who we're making it for.

One star for geography is a new one. The shake didn't get a mention, our team didn't get a mention, and the visit didn't either. Just the map.

But you found us, so it can't be that remote.

GOT FEEDBACK
WORTH SHARING?

Have something real to say? We'd rather hear it directly.