THE HALL
OF SHAME

Some reviews need a response.

Most Recent First

Michael Dixon Google Reviews
★★★★★
#Link copied

TL;DR Avoid this place if you don't want to wait 2 hours for a shake. We had to ask for a refund after waiting close to 90 minutes for our shakes (which would have taken much longer).

This place just isn't ready to open yet (even a soft open). They're understaffed and the staff don't seem like they're trained well; our cashier was super sweet but she wasn't able to put in orders quickly, and the three people in the back were somehow only making about one shake every 5-10 minutes combined (not each). Whatever training they still have to do, they need to just do it now and THEN open the store. It's ridiculous to open a shake shop in the middle of the summer and not fully train your employees before throwing them into a dessert rush.

There were about 10 people in front of us when we arrived and it still took 30 minutes to get to the front of the line because of how slow the orders were being taken. Then, after we put in our order (4 small shakes), the cashier asked for a phone number and just said the shakes would "take a while" to come out. An hour later (past 11 pm at this point), there were still EIGHT shake orders in front of us and they were serving one order every 10 minutes. We decided to just cut our losses and ask for a refund because we needed to be up early and at the rate they were serving shakes, we'd be waiting well past midnight.

If the cashier had given us an actual wait time instead of just saying "a while", we obviously wouldn't have waited. I can understand not wanting to tell your customer that a small shake will take 90 minutes to 2 hours to come out, but it's better to tell the truth and lose business once than to hide the wait time and lose business long term.

Jones' Shakes Response

Exaggerator and sign ignorer.

Unfortunately, even with a sign that warned customers that we’re understaffed, that orders could take over 30 minutes, and that we’re in the middle of a soft open, John decided to come in. No problem so far. But John’s expectations remained too high for a business who’s still training and hiring.

Worse, John characterizes the wait as 2 hours.
What a lie. He waited 38 minutes for his shake. Is that a long wait? Yes. Was it expected during our first week with the parameters above? Yes.

Imsohungry Google Reviews · Oct 16, 2026
★★★★★
#Link copied

I honestly don’t even know where to start with this place. I came in hoping for a nice, quick treat and instead got a masterclass in how not to run a shake shop. First off, the wait was absurd. There were barely any customers inside, yet it took almost 20 minutes just to get a single shake. When my cup finally made it to the counter, it was dripping sticky liquid down the sides and already melting into lukewarm sludge. As for the actual shake? Unmitigated disaster. The flavor was completely off—tasted like synthetic syrup diluted with melted ice water rather than actual cream. To make matters worse, the texture was a clumpy, separated mess. I took two sips, realized it wasn't getting any better, and threw the whole $8 cup straight into the trash. Save your money and go literally anywhere else. A cheap grocery store ice cream tub melted in the sun would taste better than whatever they’re blending up here. Completely uninspired, overpriced, and a total waste of time. Never coming back.

Jones' Shakes Response

Let's take this one slowly, since it was clearly written that way.

No date, no flavor, no order, no employee and no detail. Just a long string of insults that could have been pasted onto any ice cream shop in America. Real reviews say what you ordered and what went wrong. This one doesn't, because there's nothing specific to say. You could swap our name out for anyone else's and it would read exactly the same.

So here are the specifics.

Our shakes start with a fresh, creamy base made in our machines every day. It isn't out of a tub, and it isn't sitting in a grocery freezer for months. Our mix-ins are real: real cookies, real candy, real fruit, real pie. Every shake is made by hand by a person standing a few feet from you, and you can watch it happen at the window. Nothing is hidden in the back. Nothing about it is "cheap." Real ingredients cost more, and we pay it on purpose, because that's the difference you can taste.

As for that melted tub tasting better: honestly, we doubt you've tried it. If you have, we'd like to see that review too.

We take real feedback seriously. When a guest tells us a shake was off, we make it right, and our team hears about it the same day. That's how a new shop gets better, and it's how we've built what we have. But it only works when someone is honest about what happened. An anonymous rant with nothing specific in it doesn't help us, doesn't help the next customer, and isn't really a review.

A grudge with no details isn't a review. It's just noise, and this is the last word we'll spend on it.

Tamra Burgess Google Reviews · Sep 19, 2026
★★★★★
#Link copied

No line in front of me. I ended up Paying 20$ and Waiting over 45 minutes for 3 regular peanut butter shakes. That is actually crazy... I will never EVER go back.

Jones' Shakes Response

Tamra, it's 2026. We have the data down to the millisecond. We have the video. When we make a mistake, we'll own it. Yes, it was just over 25 minutes, not ideal, but it wasn't 45 minutes. There were four other orders going at this time and we were two workers short. If you were in a hurry and the wait was getting too long, we would have gladly refunded you given the time crunch. But you didn't say anything. Give companies 1 star when they deserve it. This is completely unfair.

Schuyler Trowbridge Google Reviews · Jul 31, 2026
★★★★★
#Link copied

They play AI contemporary Christian music in here. Shake is good but... the music is actually torture.

Jones' Shakes Response

We don't apologize for our faith, and we don't apologize for the music we play. We'll be honest: we expected comments like this, and we're not bothered by them. Who we are is part of how we run this shop, and we're not going to hide it.

But let's be accurate. Our music isn't AI. It's recorded by real artists, and we personally know most of the bands we play. These are real people who write, record and perform their own work, and we're glad to give it a place. Calling it "AI" is simply false, and it's unfair to the musicians who made it.

We put the same care into our shop that we put into our shakes. Real ingredients, made by hand, by real people. The music fits right in with that.

If a few minutes of Christian music while you wait for a shake feels like "torture," there are plenty of other places in town. We'll keep the music on.

Eric Steiner Google Reviews · May 1, 2026
★★★★★
#Link copied

Soft as a base is crazy. Worst shakes in Pensacola.

Jones' Shakes Response

Shakes are made from ice cream. That's what a shake is.

Ours start with a fresh, creamy soft-serve base, the way shake shops have done it for generations. Then we add real mix-ins like cookies, candy, fruit and pie, and blend each one by hand to order. That base is what makes a shake thick, smooth and cold all the way to the bottom of the cup.

There's nothing strange about making a shake the traditional way. It's how it's supposed to be done.

"Crazy" would be making them any other way. We'll stick with the method that works.

Henry Macke Google Reviews · Mar 6, 2026
★★★★★
#Link copied

Ai slop fest, shakes were mid felt like they used flavored powder instead of real ingredients and using soft serve as a base is terrible.

Jones' Shakes Response

There's no powder, and there's no AI making shakes.

Every shake we serve is built by hand, by a person, with real ingredients. Real cookies, real candy, real fruit and real pie go into a fresh, creamy base, and somebody on our team puts it together while you watch. There's no shortcut and no machine deciding what goes in your cup.

A soft-serve base is how a traditional shake is made. It's not a cheap substitute for something better. It's the foundation shake shops have relied on for generations, because it blends smooth and thick and carries flavor the way a shake should.

Calling that "slop" says more about the review than about the shake. We're proud of the way we make them, and we'll keep making them that way.

Haley Mazzanoble Google Reviews · Jul 28, 2025
★★★★★
#Link copied

terrible- sorry the girl was nice don’t get mad at your staff pls. cookie dough tastes like play-doh and the ice cream is water flavored.

Jones' Shakes Response

Water doesn't come out of our machines thick enough to hold a spoon.

What comes out is a fresh, creamy base, made in our machines every day, and blended by hand into every shake. It's thick because it's real, and it's creamy because that's what it's made of. Nobody's watering anything down.

Our cookie dough is real, edible cookie dough. It's a real ingredient, added by hand, the same as every other mix-in we use. We chose it because it tastes like cookie dough is supposed to taste.

We'll leave the Play-Doh comparisons to the people who've eaten it.

jason j Google Reviews · Jun 11, 2025
★★★★★
#Link copied

Google listing says they close at midnight, tried to order at 1020pm while finishing dinner, prompt came up and said they were closed.

Jones' Shakes Response

The store was open, the window was open, and we'd have made your shake.

Online ordering doesn't routinely close early. On the rare occasion it does, it's usually to keep the line at the window moving on a busy night. Every shake is made by hand, one at a time, and the people standing in line in person come first.

Even then, we weren't closed. The window was open, and the window was the way to order. All you had to do was walk up.

That's a reason to walk up, not a reason for one star.

Kristin Lindberg Google Reviews · Aug 20, 2024
★★★★★
#Link copied

If you’ve ever wondered what it’s like to pay $10 for a milkshake that tastes like someone melted down a few scoops of Great Value vanilla ice cream and sprinkled in a dash of regret, then boy, do I have the place for you. The menu was like a Where's Waldo puzzle for adults—tiny font, overwhelming options, and somehow managing to induce anxiety even though I was the *only* customer in the store. With my decent vision, I still felt like I needed a magnifying glass just to order. I chose the Spiced Peach milkshake, but "spiced" must be code for "straight-up gross." It was like drinking a smoothie made from the tears of disappointed peaches. To make things even more fun, they’ve got a menu projected onto the wall. But don't worry, you won't have to bother reading it because it's blurry enough to be considered modern art, and the sunlight streaming through the windows turns it into a lovely abstract wash of nothingness. The girl at the counter was nice, I think. I couldn’t hear half of what she was saying.

Jones' Shakes Response

Points for creativity. None for accuracy.

The menu doesn't change because the sun is out. The flavors, the ingredients and the way we make every shake are the same at noon as they are at night. Each one is made by hand, by a person, with real ingredients. Sunlight on a screen doesn't change any of that.

We have a sense of humor, and we don't mind a joke. But a review that's mostly jokes at our team's expense isn't feedback. It doesn't tell us what you ordered, what you'd change, or how we could do better. It's just aimed at people who were working hard to serve you.

That isn't criticism we can use. It's just mean.

Scot Dixon Google Reviews · Aug 4, 2024
★★★★★
#Link copied

They are NOT ready to be open yet. I've heard of soft openings, but this isn't even that. We ordered 4 shakes. That was over an hour ago, and there are still 6 orders in front of us on the board. At this rate, it'll be midnight before we get our shakes. We didn't have 2 hours to wait on four $7 small milkshakes tonight. I won't be back for a long time, if ever. These are milkshakes with two or three pre-made mix ins. I can't fathom what is taking so long. They are clearly understaffed and undertrained, yet one employee just walked out.

Jones' Shakes Response

Same night, same family, same complaint.

A soft open is a soft launch. In most places it's invite-only. We opened ours to everyone, because we wanted the whole community to be part of it from day one. We also told every guest up front that lines were running long because our team was brand new and still training. That was posted at the door and repeated at the window. Nobody walked in without knowing what kind of night it was.

You came in anyway. That was your choice. Then you held a new crew to the standard of a store that had been open for years. That isn't a fair measuring stick for people on their first nights on the job, who were working hard and learning in real time with a line out the door.

Our mix-ins are real cookies, candy, fruit and pie, added to your shake by hand. Nothing is pre-blended and nothing is shortcut. That's what a mix-in is, and it's the same way we make every shake, on opening night and every night after.

We can't know why two reviews from one household landed together, and we won't guess. A neighbor would have told us what went wrong and given a new team a second chance. You chose to post instead, and that says more than the review does.

GOT FEEDBACK
WORTH SHARING?

Have something real to say? We'd rather hear it directly.